How to Make a Cat Birthday Cake

Your cat's birthday deserves a celebration — and a cat birthday cake is the perfect centerpiece. The key is making something that looks festive to you and tastes irresistible to them. Here are three approaches, from simple to impressive.

What Makes a Safe Cat Birthday Cake?

A cat birthday cake must be:

Made from cat-safe, protein-based ingredients
Free from onions, garlic, sugar, xylitol, chocolate, and dairy in large amounts
Appropriately portioned — a birthday cake is a treat, not a meal

Option 1: The Simple Tuna Stack (5 minutes)

Ingredients:

1 can tuna in water, drained
2 tbsp plain cream cheese (small amount is safe for most cats)
Treats for decoration: Friskies Party Mix Natural YUMS

Instructions:

Press drained tuna into a small round bowl or ramekin
Flip onto a plate to create a "cake" shape
Spread a thin layer of cream cheese on top as "frosting"
Decorate with treats pressed into the top
Add a birthday candle for the photo, then remove before serving

Option 2: Baked Salmon Cake (30 minutes)

Ingredients:

1 can salmon, drained
2 eggs
1/4 cup oat flour
1 tbsp catnip (optional)

Instructions:

Preheat oven to 350°F
Mix all ingredients into a batter
Pour into a small greased ramekin or round baking dish
Bake 20–25 minutes until firm and set
Cool completely, then unmold onto a plate
Top with a thin layer of plain cream cheese and decorate with treats

Option 3: Frozen Tuna Cake (make ahead)

Ingredients:

2 cans tuna in water, drained
Low-sodium chicken broth

Instructions:

Blend tuna and a splash of broth to a smooth paste
Press into a small round container
Freeze until solid (at least 4 hours)
Unmold onto a plate and decorate with treats
Serve immediately — it will melt quickly

Making Mini Treats for Guests

If you're celebrating with multiple cats, use the Cat Treat Silicone Fish Mold to make individual fish-shaped treats for each guest. Fill with any of the recipes above and bake or freeze as appropriate.

Portion Reminder

Even on birthdays, treats should be no more than 10% of daily caloric intake. Serve a small slice and save the rest for the next few days.

Final Thoughts

A cat birthday cake is more for you than for your cat — but that's perfectly fine. The tuna stack takes 5 minutes and photographs beautifully. The baked salmon cake is more impressive and stores well. Choose based on how much time you have and how elaborate you want to go.

Back to blog